Exposure Control with Strobes
The basic goal of using strobes underwater is to provide color-balanced
light on the subject. Rarely is the strobe the only source of light.
Rather, the strobe should be seen as a brush that paints color onto a
subject. Where light from the strobe is present, you will have bright,
snappy colors. Where it is not present, colors will be muted and/or blue.
If the presence of a strobe is obvious in your picture, you have
probably done something wrong. When used properly, the strobe will light
your scene evenly but almost undetectably--except for the colors, of
course! The first step to making your strobe light work properly is
exposure control, and that's what this section is all about. The basic
goal here is to balance the strobe light with the ambient light. With
wide-angle photography, when there's lots of water in the background, this
is critical. For macro photography, it's not so critical, but is more of a
nicety. Sometimes it's just not feasible to have balanced backgrounds in
Goldilocks says "this one is too cold!" In
other words, the subject doesn't have enough color--I didn't apply
enough strobe light!
"This one is too hot!" This picture shows
what happens when your strobe is too bright--your subject doesn't
balance with the background!
"This one is just right!"
Ahhhhh...balanced subject & background, which is our goal.
Exposure Modes: TTL and Manual
I'm going to do this section in a sort of backwards way, in the sense
that I'm going to cover the more complex method first. The reason for this
is that there are a few concepts that you need to understand before we can
talk in detail about the simpler method, and those concepts are integral
to the more complex method.
There are two ways you can control your
strobe intensity, namely TTL ("Through The Lens")
and manual. In TTL control,
the camera controls the strobe, shutting it off when it thinks the film
has seen enough light. In manual
strobe control, you control the strobe, setting a power level
that is appropriate for your picture. Both of these topics are covered in
the Exposure 101 section, but some of the
concepts are worth repeating just to have a second explanation. If you
haven't read Exposure 101, you should probably read it now, just in case.
The basic idea behind manual strobe control is that you set the
aperture, shutter speed, and strobe power to fit your scene. You have
information at your disposal that the camera simply does not have, namely
the distance between the strobe and the subject, along with the strobe
power. You can use this information to nail the exposure perfectly, while
the camera has to guesstimate the situation based on parameters programmed
into it by the camera designers.
Remember the goal here: get a
balanced exposure, where the strobe light and background (or
"ambient") light are at the same level. Some people like to
have the strobe light a little weaker than the background, but that's a
personal choice. I'm going to show you how to get them perfectly balanced,
and you can fiddle with it yourself if you want a weaker strobe.
the overview: you want to meter the water so you know how bright it is.
Then you use the strobe-to-subject distance (you'll have to eyeball that
yourself, each picture) plus the guide number equation or the strobe's
exposure table to figure out a strobe power and aperture combination that
makes sense. Then, once you have the aperture set, you pick a shutter
speed that exposes the background (water, frequently) at the same level as
the subject. Sounds pretty easy, doesn't it?
In practice, though,
it's a little more complicated. Here's a sort of flow chart of
getting good strobe exposure. I commonly go through this at least once on
every shot. I shoot all my wide-angle shots in 'A' mode, where I set an
aperture and the camera tells me what shutter speed will give me proper
exposure for that aperture.
- Estimate strobe-to-subject distance, or position subject at a known
- Use strobe's exposure chart to find proper aperture for this
distance (you also need to know your film speed to do this). My
primary strobe has 4 power settings: full, 1/2, 1/4, 1/8. I usually
start at 1/2 or 1/4 because that gives me one stop in each direction
if I need to match power to aperture in step 8.
- Set aperture on camera
- Point camera at background and trigger the light meter (usually a
light press on the shutter does this)
- Camera is in 'A' mode, so it gives a shutter speed. The camera also
indicates whether that shutter speed needs to be longer (it has a
floor at 1/60) or shorter (its max sync speed is 1/250). This is
important, because if 1/60 is not long enough and I shoot at 1/60,
I'll get a dark background. Similarly, if 1/250 is too long, I'll get
an overexposed background.
- If the shutter is inadequate (long or short), adjust the aperture
one stop in the right direction (i.e. "needs longer than
1/60" means open the aperture one stop, "needs shorter than
1/250" means that close down one stop) & try again.
- Repeat 6 until a reasonable shutter & aperture is reached.
Usually only one cycle is required.
- Adjust strobe power using exposure table to match new aperture
- Focus, compose, and shoot!
By way of example, it's worth mentioning that the way I shoot most
pictures is considerably easier. I put my strobe on 1/4 power and my
aperture on f/5.6. Then my strobe's exposure chart tells me that I should
be 3.6 feet from my subject. If it's possible to put my subject 3 feet
from the camera and get the shot I want, I do so, and shoot (remember 3
apparent feet is actually 4 feet underwater). Underwater, f/5.6 and ISO
100 film almost always results in shutter speeds between 1/125 and 1/250.
If it's a bright day, I use 1/2 power and f/8 instead.
If I need to move closer (the next distance on the strobe's exposure
chart is 2.5 feet), I either go down one power setting on the strobe or
close down one stop on the camera. If I'm shooting from father away (5
feet is the next farther setting), I either go one setting higher on
strobe power or open up one stop on the lens. Since virtually everything I
shoot is between 2.5 and 5 feet, this covers 90% of the pictures I shoot.
Anything closer than 2.5 feet or farther than 5 requires the 9-step
process outlined above.
TTL Strobe Control
TTL strobe control is a method where the camera watches the light build
up on the film and shuts off the strobe when it thinks the lighting is
right. Read the chapter on TTL
strobe usage in the Exposure 101 section if you'd like some more
specific information. Basically, though, you expect to use TTL strobe
control in only a few cases. Macro work, for instance, is extremely
well-suited to TTL strobe control, because you are basically going to
light the entire scene from your strobes. In macro work, the goal is to
fill the frame with as much of the subject as possible. In this case,
you're not worried about balancing the strobe to the background, because
there might not be a background!
TTL strobe control also generally works
well with fish portraits, especially if the subject is a large portion of
the frame. If your subject is not a large portion of the frame, though,
the camera is going to try to balance the whole picture. Since the light
that does not strike the subject goes off into the water, the camera is
probably going to let the strobe run longer than necessary--it wants an
overall exposure level, so it will let the subject get bright enough until
the total light is high enough. The net result of this is usually a
bright subject on a dark background, which is not the goal.
you use TTL control, it's still a good idea to pick an aperture that will
result in reasonable shutter speeds, a la the 9-step method described for
manual strobe control. Just because you're in TTL mode with the strobe,
don't forget to make sure the background water is can be balanced with the
strobe. You should think of TTL strobe control as relieving you from
having to do the strobe-to-subject distance calculation, but nothing else.
Balancing the strobe against the ambient light is still your
responsibility! Of course, if you decide you want to go to f/32 for your
macro shot in order to maximize your depth of field, that's your
choice...but be prepared for black water for your background!
Chapter | Strobes